This article on CNN about Troy Davis got me thinking about the death penalty again. Having never heard of this case I did a little digging around on google and found some information about his trial and appeals. Personally, I think the death penalty is the stupidest thing I’ve ever heard of. State sanctioned murder? No thanks. Sounds more like vengeance than justice to me. Closure for the victims? That makes no logical sense. I’d rather have someone rot in jail the rest of their life.
I won’t go over all the details since you can read about the case in so many places, but a few things struck me as odd. And by odd I mean fucked up. The short version:
1) The murder weapon was never found, although the .38 caliber that most likely killed the officer was owned by a friend of Davis who was there, was a suspect himself and testified against him.
Coles initially lied about carrying the .38 caliber revolver, but later admitted to carrying it with him on the night of the murder. He claimed that it was lost when the police attempted to recover the gun for testing.
Uh huh. Lost it, sure.
2) Seven of the nine “witnesses” recanted their sworn affidavits after the trial (one that didn’t change his story was Coles, the other suspect in the case).
Many of them state they never read the typed up affidavits before they signed them and didn’t want to get into any trouble with the cops themselves. Sounds like a bunch of reliable people to me! Bet your life on it?
3) The district attorney isn’t losing any sleep over it.
Second, they claim that seven of nine witnesses have recanted their trial testimony. This is not believable.
To be sure, they’ve produced affidavits; a few handwritten and apparently voluntarily and spontaneous, except for concluding with “further the affiant sayeth not.” Who wrote that stuff? The lawyers, perhaps?
The law is understandably skeptical of post-trial “newly-discovered evidence.”
Such evidence as these affidavits might, for example, be paid for, or coerced, or the product of fading memory.
So statements before the trial can’t possibly be coerced, but after the trial they probably were? Read the rest of his opinion piece. The man sounds like an idiot.
This is all it takes to put someone to death? Sounds pretty flimsy to me.

Oh now I get it. He’s black and this happened in Georgia. My bad.